Image description: Prince of Thorns book cover by Mark Lawrence |
Back when this blog was young, I did a best sci/fi or fantasy poll and even with only twenty readers, I somehow ended up in a seven part poll with over a hundred nominations, so I've spent a lot of time trying to break those genres into smaller subsets for the purposes of running a poll that didn't take months. A year and change ago I was doing best classic sci fi, best modern sci fi, best stand alone sci fi, best stand alone fantasy, best sci fi series, best fantasy series, best classic fantasy...
But I somehow forgot best modern fantasy. So here we go.
Rules-
1- As always, I leave the semantics about "fantasy" to your best judgement because I'd rather be inclusive. I might arch an eyebrow at your ridiculous stretch to get, but I'm not going to argue.
2- To avoid multi-decade spanning series being on our poll because an author tossed out a recent sequel, the book OR FIRST BOOK IN THE SERIES must have a copyright date no earlier than 1992. If your series kicked off in the eighties, you'll have to pick one book (that came later) to nominate.
3- You may nominate two (2) works of modern fantasy. Remember that I am a terrifying megalomaniac who hates free will and all things that smell like liberty. I will NOT take any books or series beyond the second that you suggest. (I will consider everything after your second rec in a long list to be "seconds" if the work is nominated before or after yours.)
3- You may (and should) second as many nominations of others as you wish. That is the only way they'll be making it to the final poll.
4- Please put your nominations here. I will take nominations on reminder posts; however, they may not get the seconds you need to go onto our poll because no one will see them. But I can't sift through all the social media cross posting. (Seriously, Deloris Umbridge got a nomination on our best villain poll, but she received no seconds because she was nominated on Facebook instead of here. And then everyone got sad that she wasn't on the polls–though she probably should have been.)
5- You are nominating WRITTEN WORKS, not their movie portrayals. CGI epic fights might be very pretty, but if you found Game of Thrones to be too dense a read (I didn't, but just by way of example), you shouldn't nominate it because Kit Harrington rocks a tux.
6- "Best" means whatever you as a reader think it should. Most challenging. Most engaging. Most fun. Most literary. It's up to you what "best" means.
I nominate
ReplyDelete1) The Travelers Gate series by Will Wight
And
2) Dawn of Wonder: The Wakening by Jonathan Renshaw
I second Dawn of Wonder. Probably my favourite fantasy novel.
DeleteThe Magaicians' Guild (first in the Black Magician Trilogy) by Truck Canavan
ReplyDeleteSeconded (and thank you, I was having trouble picking just two!)
Delete*Trudy Canavan. Gotta love autocorrect!
Ack! *Trudi Canavan
DeleteI nominate The Kingkiller Chronicle, both "The Name of the Wind" and "Wise Man's Fear".
ReplyDeleteI second!
DeleteI third!!!
DeleteSeconded/thirded/fourtheth this suggestion too
DeleteQuinded
DeleteSeconded!
DeleteSeconded
Deletethis ^
Deleteseconded
DeleteHexed.
DeleteAgreed!
DeleteAgreed
DeleteDragon Apocalypse by James Maxey
ReplyDeleteThe Dresden Files by Jim Butcher
Those are my nominations
Dresden Files by Jim Butcher, seconded.
DeleteI will second The Dresden Files all day long
DeleteAll Dresden, All Day!
DeleteSeconded. All hail the Zza Lord.
DeleteSecond the Dresden Files.
DeleteSecond Dresden Files!
DeleteSecond Dresden Files!
DeleteI nominate American Gods, by Neil Gaiman.
ReplyDeleteI second American Gods!
DeleteThird!
DeleteI nominate
ReplyDelete1. Garden of the moon (Book 1 of Malazan series) - Steven Erikson
2. American Gods - Neil Gaiman
Seconding Steven Erickson's Malazan.
DeleteWas going to enter this absolute gem in myself. I 'third' the Malazan Book of the Fallen. Hands down the most challenging and creative fantasy work in recent times.
DeleteSecond Gardens of the Moon. I feel there is no debate here.
DeleteAs soon as I saw this, the Malazan Book of the Fallen popped into my head. I fourth.
DeleteI fourth Malazan Book of the Fallen. Amazing. It's what inspired me to write.
DeleteI second American Gods
DeleteN.K. Jemisin's The Inheritance Trilogy.
ReplyDeleteSeconded.
DeleteThird!
DeleteI will second anything N. K. Jemisin writes all day long!
DeleteThe Iron Druid Chronicles by Kevin Hearne.
ReplyDeleteSeconded!
DeleteThe Riyria Revelations by Michael J. Sullivan.
ReplyDeleteSeconded
DeleteThirded
DeleteFourtheted
DeleteDiscworld, all of it!
ReplyDeleteAlas, The Colour of Magic came oot in 1983, and the limit is 1992 at the earliest fer this poll, otherwise I'd be seconding
DeleteBut he did say we can also choose any book in the series that was published after 1992.
DeleteAh sae he did, in that case it'll have tae be any book after Small Gods inclusively
DeleteOh snap. This poll just got interesting.
DeleteSeconded. With Octarine gusto.
Robert Sanderson's Mistborn series
ReplyDeleteBrandon Sanderson and I second this.
DeleteI third this!
DeleteI fourth this
DeleteFifth!
DeleteSixth!
DeleteSeconded again!
DeleteSeconded!
DeleteBrandon Sanderson's Stormlight Chronicles.
ReplyDeleteI very strongly agree for a variety of reasons.
DeleteOne it's a really well done creative world that is presented smoothly from different pov.
Two it handles and tackles some really hard mental health issues tactfully and thoroughly without feeling hamfisted OR taking away from the characters.
Plus each book just leaves you wanting the next so hard.
Seconded
DeleteI third! Sanderson is a standout fantasy author.
DeleteFourth. Brilliant series from an outstanding author.
DeleteFifth. Hands down!
DeleteSixth! Amazing series!
DeleteI support this also.
DeleteSupporting this all the way, though I still think Shadows of Self is my favourite by him.
DeleteI second this though I'm not the first to do so.
Deletesecond of my votes (:
DeleteAmerican Gods by Neil Gaiman
ReplyDeleteThe ocean at the end of the lane by Neil Gaiman
A song of fire and ice by George R. R. Martin
Harry Potter bt J.K. Rowling
Discworld by Terry Pratchett
Second to American Gods, A song of ice and fire, and Harry Potter.
DeleteAmerican Gods. Yes.
Delete1) Garth Nix's Keys to the Kingdom
ReplyDelete2) Derek Landy's Skulduggery Pleasant
Yuss. I remember having a lot of fun reading Keys to the Kingdom when I was a kid <3
DeleteJonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell by Susanna Clarke
ReplyDeleteGive a second on that, brilliant novel.
DeleteSeconded.
DeleteThe Powder Mage Trilogy by Brian McClellan.
ReplyDeleteSeconded
Delete1. Night Watch by Terry Pratchett
ReplyDelete2. Mistborn series by Brandon Sanderson
I second Night Watch
DeleteSecond Mistborne
DeleteI third Night Watch. Sam Vimes for President 2020
DeleteThe Alchemyst
ReplyDeleteThe Subtle Knife
Age of the Five (series) - Trudi Canavan
ReplyDeleteLightbringer (series) - Brent Weeks
Second Brent weeks light bringer series
DeleteSecond light bringer as well
DeleteI nominate Tales from Earthsea and the follow up books ending with The Other Wind - by Ursula K. Le Guin.
ReplyDeleteSeconded. Brilliant stuff.
DeleteFor my second nomination, I would like to add The First Law trilogy, by Joe Abercrombie.
ReplyDeleteSeconded!
DeleteThird(ed)
DeleteFourth(ed)
DeleteI nominate Steven Eriksen's Malazan Book of the Fallen series.
ReplyDeleteSeconding it!
DeleteSecond second!
DeleteStrongly seconded.
DeleteThe series is one of a kind in world building and commands a prose that keeps the world alive in every step. It is known to be challenging because the clunky usage of exposition used as a crutch by many fantasy writers is something hardly seen here.
Characters like Kruppe and Anomander Rake command as much respect as Gandalf and Severus Snape.
I will join you fair folks on this oh-so-noble quest.
DeleteI nominate:
ReplyDelete1. The Chronicles of the Necromancer by Gail Z. Martin
2. The Kingmaker Chronicles by Amanda Bouchet
Wheel of Time series: Robert Jordan
ReplyDeleteThe Wheel of Time...Eye of the World, was published in 1990. Just a heads up, as the first book is slightly out of the 25 year time frame.
DeleteI nominate Guild hunter series and Psy-changeling series by Nalini Singh
ReplyDeleteHow the Dead Live by Will Self
ReplyDeleteThe Raw Shark Texts by Steven Hall
Seconds for A Song of Ice and Fire and Harry Potter.
I nominate the Farseer Trilogy and the Liveship Trader series, both by Robin Hobb.
ReplyDeleteSeconded both
DeleteSecond the Farseer trilogy. I enjoyed the live ships but not enough to second it.
DeleteI second both!
Delete1. A darker shade of magic - V.E. Schwab
ReplyDelete2. This Savage Song - V.E. Schwab
Seriously, I wanted to nominate all V.E. Schwab's books, but I just went with these two as representatives of her amazing writing
I nominate the Legend of Drizzt series by R.A. Salvatore.
ReplyDeleteI nominate Skulduggery Pleasant: Mortal Coil by Derek Landy
ReplyDeleteNominating Malazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson, before Esselmont shat all over it.
ReplyDeleteAlso nominating the City Watch series by Terry Pratchett.
Seconding Malazan book of the fallen.
DeleteThird for the Book of the Fallen. Though, mate don't be silly. Have you read Dancer's Lament by Ian C. Esslemont? The guy has talent.
DeleteStorm of Swords by George RR Martin
ReplyDeleteI nominate:
ReplyDelete1) The Night Angel Trilogy by Brent Weeks
2) The Lightbringer Series by Brent Weeks
Second both of these
DeleteI second both of these!
DeleteThe Prince of Nothing series by R. Scott Bakker
ReplyDeleteThe Kingdoms of Thorn and Bone by Gregory Keyes (peeps should Reads these)
Just read the first one. Promising start.
DeleteThe Golden Key by Melanie Rawn, Jennifer Roberson, and Kate Elliott. (c. 1999 by DAW Books Inc.
ReplyDeleteThe limits of 25 years exclude books like Tigana by Guy Gavriel Kay
Seconding The Golden Key - wonderful book, ingenious premise, excellent writing.
DeleteI nominate;
ReplyDeleteSawyer Jackson and the Long Land
(Trilogy)
By Kevin Tumlinso
*Tumlinson
DeleteSorry, my screen is cracked 😭
1) Radiance - Catherynne M. Valente
ReplyDelete2) Uprooted - Naomi Novik
I'll second Uprooted.
DeleteI second both of these.
DeleteKingkiller Chronicle- Patrick Rothfuss
ReplyDeleteNight Angel Series - Brent Weeks
Seconded
DeleteSecond night angel
DeleteKing killer chronicles seconded
DeleteTrinity series by Fiona McIntosh
ReplyDeleteThe Chronicles of Kaya by Charlotte McConaghy
Some books to nominate, why yes:
ReplyDelete1. Malazan Book of the Fallen - Steven Erickson
2. The Last Wish - Andrzej Sapkowski (Witcher series)
Kruppe is broken hearted to not say Harry Potter for he can only name two. But no worries, for we will hear of that very much too.
And please give my apologies to Tyrion should one see him as well. I do enjoy his work.
😍
DeleteI second The Last Wish. It's brilliant.
DeleteKings of Grace by Ken Liu, I mean come on now, this book is a work of art
ReplyDeleteEverfair, by Nisi Shawl
ReplyDeleteSecond!
DeleteThe Brothers Leviathan, by Zig Zag Claybourne
ReplyDeleteI also nominate Nnedi Okorafor for Who Fears Death.
ReplyDeleteSeconded!
DeleteI nominate the Name of the Wind 'trilogy' by Patrick Rothfuss.
ReplyDeleteSeconded!
Delete1. The Bartimaeus Trilogy by Jonathan Stroud
ReplyDelete2. Biased as I may be, I'll throw Kasigah - Witch Hunt into the ring as well
1. the wise oak series by Oliver Tooley (I'm possibly a little biased, but I genuinely think it's an excellent, historically grounded fantasy)
ReplyDelete2. the black book of secrets by F.E. Higgins (possibly stretching the definition of fantasy a little, but there are certainly fantasy elements, and that's good enough for me)
A Song of Ice and Fire series by George R.R. Martin and the Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling
ReplyDeleteSecond Potter
Deletesecond Harry Potter
DeleteSecond Potter.
DeleteI nominate The First Law trilogy by Joe Abercrombie
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely. Great series. The only remarkable flaw is the ending which is not the greatest. The bulk of the novels are quality though.
DeleteChanga's Safari One, Two and Three by Milton Davis
ReplyDeleteSeconded.
DeleteAbengoni: First Calling by Charles R. Saunders.
ReplyDeleteSeconded.
DeleteSabriel (the Abhorson trilogy) by Garth Nix
ReplyDeleteand
East by Edith Pattou
I'll second East
DeleteI second Sabriel.
DeleteMalazan Book of the Fallen by Steven Erikson
ReplyDeleteKingkiller Chronicle by Patrick Rothfuss
By far the two most influential and significant fantasy series in my life
The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern
ReplyDeleteNeverwhere by Neil Gaiman
I second Neverwhere. I know everyone's all hyped about American Gods, but Neverwhere is Gaiman's best book.
DeleteI second the night circus! Absolutely amazing!
DeleteSeconding Neverwhere. It had this big beautiful feel of magic for me that American Gods lacked.
DeleteI third Night Circus
DeleteHIS DARK MATERIALS, Philip Pullman
ReplyDeleteSeconded.
DeleteThe Ydron Saga series, Raymond Bolton
ReplyDeleteStormlight was my first.. but hey.. it's already listed!
The Kingkiller Chronicles. Nothing compares.
ReplyDeleteNominating
ReplyDelete1.) The Gentleman Bastard series by Scott Lynch (Specifically the first book, "The Lies of Locke Lamora" since it's the best imo, but the whole series is amazing fantasy)
2.) The Magicians trilogy by Lev Grossman. One of my favorite all-time books. Like Harry Potter for adults, can't get better than that!
And I know we only get two but American Gods by Neil Gaiman was a close 2nd, amazing book. Lots of people already said it though :)
Mikes Camerons 'Red Knight' and 'The Fell Sword'
ReplyDeleteMiles*
DeleteSeconding Magicians, by Lev Grossman
Delete1) Nalini Singh: Psy-Changeling Series
ReplyDeleteAnd
2) Nalini Singh: Guild Hunter Series
I nominate:
ReplyDeleteScythe by Neal Shusterman
I nominate:
ReplyDelete1. A Monster Calls - Patrick Ness
2. The Rest of Us Just Live Here - Patrick Ness
Two of the most emotionally fascinating books I've ever read. Though perhaps aimed at a younger audience than some of the others suggested, they both did a wonderful job of using fantasy elements to highlight the emotional state of the protagonists in a way I hadn't seen before.
Beyond those two, I'd have to second any books by Brandon Sanderson, and The Chimes by Anna Smaill.
Seconding The Rest of Us Just Live Here.
DeleteR. Scott Bakker's Prince of Nothing trilogy is absolutely brilliant
ReplyDeleteAnne bishop
ReplyDeleteBlack jewels
second!
DeleteI nominate:
ReplyDelete1 - Way of kings series - Brandon Sanderson
2 - The Belgariad - David Eddings
I second the Belgariad
DeleteThe First Law - Joe Abercrombie
ReplyDeleteThe Dresden Files - Jim Butcher
ReplyDeleteThe Demon Cycle - Peter V. Brett
Percy Jackson and the Olympians - Rick Riordan
ReplyDeleteBeyond this, everyone has covered the series I would nominate, complete with seconds, and the only other ones I can think of are stand-alone novels or were started before 1992...
Certainly this poll is already going to be epic, but stand alone is okay. :)
DeleteYes, I second Percy Jackson!
DeleteSeconding Percy Jackson
DeleteThe Hollows series by Kim Harrison
ReplyDeleteSeconding Kim Harrison's The Hollows.
DeleteKushiel's Legacy by Jacqueline Carey
ReplyDeleteSecond!!! My gods LOVE this series
DeleteI'm going to nominate a book that may not be known by many other non-librarians, but The Underneath by Kathi Appelt is one of the most beautiful, magical books I have ever read. The only reason it didn't win the Newbery is because Neil Gaiman wrote another amazing book called The Graveyard Book that same year. But at the end of it all, I choose The Underneath as my second nomination.
ReplyDeleteThe Mercy Thompson Series by Patricia Briggs
ReplyDeleteYes! Seconded!
DeleteAlso xeconding Patricia Briggs' Mercy Thompson series
DeletePriest (Ratcatchers Book 1) by Matthew Colville
ReplyDeleteand Thief (Ratcatchers Book 2)
October Daye by Seanan McGuire.
ReplyDeleteSeconded enthusiastically!
DeleteNominating:
ReplyDelete1. Libriomancer series by Jim C. Hines
2. Hold Me Closer, Necromancer by Lish McBride
Second Libriomancer
DeleteDo graphic novels count? If so, Digger by Ursula Vernon. If not, can we have a poll for them? :D (because you clearly don't have enough to do already!)
ReplyDeleteEvery Heart a Doorway by Seanan McGuire
And if Digger doesn't count, my second nomination is the Kitty Norville series by Carrie Vaughn. If Digger does count, call that a second if someone else wants to nominate it :)