Edit: Nominations are closed. The reader generated poll is here:
http://www.chrisbrecheen.com/2016/01/best-magic-system-semifinal-1.html
What is the best system of magic in a book or book series?
While I give you one more day to get the last votes in on our Best Dystopia Poll (on the lower left side), let's get started on our January poll before it gets too late in the month.
Magic systems vary greatly from authorial hand waving (it's magic....whatever), complicated systems of exactly what magic can do and how, all the way to every single person having their own unique magical talent with severe limitations.
Which one is the best? "Best" might mean most interesting, most well thought out, most well explained, most imagination grabbing. Or perhaps you are more particular to described in exquisite living detail or just a funny cavalcade of "miscasts" when someone uses magic who can't handle it. Use whatever criteria you decide makes for the best magic system.
The Rules
1- As always, I leave the niggling to your best judgement because I'd rather be inclusive. If you feel like time travelers from the future using quantum fields to basically do magic, I'm not going to argue that it doesn't count. (Though you might need to "show your work" to get anyone to second your nomination.)
2- Since magic systems are typically part of the setting of a book, the nominations can be for a single book, a series, or several series that all use the same magic system.
3- You may nominate two (2) works with magic systems you like. Remember that I am a terrifying megalomaniac who hates free will and all things that smell like liberty. To encourage reading and reading comprehension I will NOT take any magic systems beyond the second that you suggest. (I will consider a long list to be "seconds" if someone else nominates them as well.)
3- You may (and should) second as many nominations of others as you wish. That is the only way they'll be making it to the final poll
4- Please put your nominations here. I will take magic systems nominated as comments to this post on other social media (Facebook or G+ for example); however, they may not get the seconds you need to go onto our poll because no one will see them. (Seriously, Deloris Umbridge got a nomination on our best villain poll, but she received no seconds because she was nominated on Facebook instead of here. And then everyone got sad that she wasn't on the polls.)
5- You are nominating WRITTEN MAGIC SYSTEMS, not their movie portrayals. CGI epic Battle of Hogwart's fights might be very pretty, but if you find the Harry Potter magic system in the books to be a little stifling and inconsistent with what can be done with or without a wand in hand, you shouldn't nominate that world.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
-
How being a writer helped me rewrite a sexist trope...for real. [Edit 3 (7/25/13): I speak to some of the more common comments, questions,...
-
Well....it finally happened. My "can't even" about the comments on my Facebook page went from figurative to literal. At o...
-
So if you've been on Facebook sometime in the last fifty years or so, you've probably run across this little turd of a meme. I...
-
My suspicion is we're going to hear a lot about mental illness in the next few days. A lot. And my prediction is that it's going to...
-
Come see the full comic at: http://jensorensen.com/2016/11/15/donald-trump-election-win-reactions-cartoon/ If you are still trying to ...
-
Image description: A fountain pen writing on lined paper. These are the brass tacks. The bare bones. The pulsing core of effective writi...
-
Ready to do some things for your craft that will terrify you even more than a sewer-dwelling clown? Oh what I wouldn't give for a si...
-
I don't normally mess with author gossip here on Writing About Writing . Our incestual little industry has enough tricky-to-navigate g...
-
This might be a personal question, but I saw that you once used to be Muslim on one of your other posts. Why did you leave? It's fun...
-
1. Great writing involves great risk–the risk of terrible writing. Writing that involves no risk is merely forgettable–utterly. 2. When yo...
Allomancy from Brandon Sanderson's Mistborn series. (Feruchemy, and Hemalurgy are good too, but Allomancy is the best developed)
ReplyDeleteSecond
DeleteTrue Source from Robert´s Jordan Wheel of Time.
ReplyDeleteSeconded, although i wouldn't specify just True Source but the magic system in the series overall.
DeleteJim Butcher's Dresden Files
ReplyDeleteDavid Eddings' Belgariad.
I'll second both of these. Especially Butcher's Dresden series.
DeleteNomination #1:
ReplyDeleteThe bard's musical magic in the Quarters Novels by Tanya Huff.
I realize this might be an obscure one, but one of my absolute faves.
From Olga Godim on Goodreads:
In Shkoder, bards can see kigh, elemental creatures of air, fire, water, and earth. With their music and their Songs, the bards of Shkoder can command the kigh to do their bidding: carry messages across the land, ignite or extinguish fires, infuse the soil with fertility, or remove water from a flooded path. It is an utterly original concept of magic, and the stronger the bard, the more powerful he or she is with their elements. Some bards can command two or more elements. Annice can command all four: she Sings the four quarters.
Nomination #2:
The Peter Grant series by Ben Aaronovitch
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteMercedes Lackey's Elemental Magic series is very well done & gives a different type of magic. The Five Hundred Kingdoms series gives magic (& fairy tales) from the points of view of the Godmothers. Her Valdemar series gives some great explanations of different magic schools as well as having mind magic.
ReplyDeleteTamora Pierce's Tortall series showcases more traditional as well as wild magic. Her Magic Circle series covers young mages learning magic through crafting and nontraditional means.
Er...that's more than two series, but at least I kept it to two authors!
Second Mercedes Lackey's any kind of magic!
DeleteI've always been a fan of how magic is treated in Patricia C. Wrede's Dragons series. There is a good distinction between wizards, witches, dragons, and magicians, and how each of them uses magic. Primarily, though, I love how the magic of the Enchanted Forest is like a grid of threads that the King and Queen can feel and manipulate, it's tied specifically to their rightful rule.
ReplyDeleteSeconding Wrede.
DeleteI like the system from Dickenson's Dragon and the George series.
ReplyDeleteLois Bujold's The Sharing Knife.
ReplyDeleteI will second that!
DeleteSeconding Valdemar, seconding Wheel of Time.
ReplyDeleteNominating Dave Duncan's A Man of His Word series (Magic Casement, Faery Lands Forlorn, etc.) This was one of the first series I ever read, and Rap and Inos are among my favorite characters ever.
Reserving my second nomination for in case I can think of the one on the tip of my tongue - otherwise I'll come back and pick one of the below.
Including here others I'm very fond of in the hopes someone nominates them.
The Spellsong Cycle (Soprano Sorceress); and the Order Wars, both by L. E. Modesitt, Jr.
Black Jewels by Anne Bishop
Tales of the Kings Blades (Gilded Chain) and Seventh Sword series (Reluctant Swordsman) also by Dave Duncan
Kim Harrison's The Hallows / Rachel Morgan series
Order and Chaos from the Recluse series by L.E. Modesitt Jr.
ReplyDeleteStormlight from the Stormlight Archives by Brandon Sanderson
Seconded to both
Delete#1. Marjorie B. Kellogg's The Dragon Quartet
ReplyDelete#2. Sara Douglass's The Wayfarer Redemption trilogy
CM Scott
His Dark Materials by Phillip Pullman
ReplyDeleteNomination: Ursula Le Guin's Earthsea books. Wizard of Earthsea, Tombs of Atuan, Farthest Shore, Tehanu.
ReplyDeleteBias: I first read them at a formative age, before I'd heard of Taoism. The showdown between Sparrowhawk and the Dragon of Pendor remains one of my favorite tense scenes. I love the interplay of perspectives: there's the school at Roke, with Master Windkey and Master Namer and so forth, but that's not the only way to understand magic, and "rules change in the Reaches". Also, bonus for Le Guin returning to the setting, decades after the trilogy, and bringing her own shifts of perspective to telling other sides of the story with "Tehanu".
Second: The Sharing Knife (and sequels) by Bujold.
I also love what "Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality" did with Rowling's setting and system.
I second The Earthsea trilogy by Ursula Le Guin. (Was going to post that myself if I hadn't seen it here.)
DeleteSecond Dickson's "Dragon & The George" first book in the "Dragon Knight" series.
ReplyDeleteSecond LeGuine's Earthsea
Nominating
ReplyDeleteHodgell's "Kencyrath"
Carey's "Felix Castor"
Second Kencyrath
DeleteI second Wheel of Time's system, and I'll add a nomination for The Magicians series by Lev Grossman. I like that magic isn't easy in that series, it requires years of boring book work and precise wording and movement to make it work, but when it does it can tear down worlds.
ReplyDeleteNominating Jim Hines' Libriomancer series because (1) Magic with books, (2) LIBRARIES, and (3) Magic + Libraries + Books + Librarians!
ReplyDelete1) The summoning magic from Patricia McKillip's "Forgotten Beasts of Eld."
ReplyDelete2) The Witches' magic from the Diskworld Series.
Seconding the nomination for the naming magic from the Earthsea series. That's still one of the most magical feeling magic systems I've ever read.
Seconding Discworld. Witching is a bit like nursing, and counseling, and caring all over the place.
DeleteI second Wrede's Dragon Series and Discworld.
ReplyDeleteI'll nominate Riordan's Percy Jackson series (both of them). I like the interplay between magic and technology.
ReplyDeleteAlso nominate Patricia McKillip's Riddlemaster of Hed series. An amazingly organic approach to magic.
Steven Brust - both Dragaeran and Human magics from the Dragaera world
ReplyDeleteNora Roberts - witch magics from the Cousins O'Dwyer trilogy. She uses the same system in other series as well, but I think it was most detailed in that one.
Seconding Brust's Draegera
DeleteSeconding Nora Roberts
DeleteSeconding Nora Roberts
DeleteMargaret Weis and Tracy Hickman's "Death Gate Cycle"; there were several different expressions of it, including tattooed runes and song/dance.
ReplyDeleteI nominate Sympathy from the Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfuss.
ReplyDeleteI second the nomination of the Kingkiller Chronicles, but I wouldn't limit it to Sympathy (although I do love it); Naming is what Rothfuss calls the "real" magic.
DeleteI nominate Sympathy from the Kingkiller Chronicles by Patrick Rothfuss.
ReplyDeleteSeconding Patricia McKillip - anything by her, really. All her magic is quirky and understated and lovely
ReplyDelete